Team Giants


Special Report

Sent: 11-28-18

Dave Klein was the Giants' beat writer for The Star-Ledger from 1961 to 1995.
He is the author of 26 books and he is one of only three sportswriters to have covered all the Super Bowls. Dave has allowed TEAM GIANTS to reprint some of his articles.


By Aaron Klein

It seems like yesterday the Giants were all full of excitement and momentum, talking about running the table for a chance to qualify for the post-season and the big things every NFL team desire most.

In fact, for most of the first half of Sunday's game in Philadelphia, it looked like all that stuff was, just maybe, real. Had the Giants turned the corner? It sure seemed as though they could defeat the defending Super Bowl champs, get to four wins, close the gap in the NFC East a bit and take aim at a depleted Chicago Bears team next week in hopes of notching one more conference victory and really get into the meat of a winning streak.

Just like that, however, it was all gone.

And now, with dreams of sugar plums, winning streaks and playoff berths dashed to the rocks, the Giants are back to figuring out what happened, who is to blame and where do they go from here anyway?

You want to blame it on Eli Manning, don't you? In part, that would be fair, but it might be a bit of a reach. Sure, he threw an ill-advised pass that wound up being intercepted near the end zone. Yes, he missed a wide-open Rhett Ellison in the end zone on a failed (and ill-advised) two-point conversion.

However, he hit 26 of 37 passes for 297 yards, one touchdown and one interception, and he also suffered two sacks and several pressures/hits. Manning wasn't great despite the numbers but had rookie Saquon Barkley been utilized more in the second half with the same success as the first, Manning's performance would have been good enough to win.

Head coach Pat Shurmur has announced that Manning will be the starter next week against Chicago, and he was quick to chastise a media that continued to ask when rookie Kyle Lauletta would finally start so that the team could "see what it has."

"Why are you jumping over Alex Tanney?" Shurmur asked. The coach pointed out that Tanney is the No. 2 and proposed a scenario that would see the journeyman, and not the rookie, being the next man up. It's a fair point. Don't you think that Lauletta would be the No. 2 instead of Tanney if he was ready? Remember, Lauletta has not even been active all season, and if you saw him in the pre-season and at camp, you should know that he has plenty to learn. Tanney, while not as athletically gifted as Lauletta, is certainly more polished and experienced.

Manning has no concerns about the team looking ahead over the final five weeks despite the likelihood that the playoff dream is over.

"I think we've been practicing well." Manning said. "We've been playing tough games and being competitive. All the games we've played, they've been close. The ones we've won have been close and down to the wire. The same last week. In this league, you got to make the plays in the critical moments, and we didn't do it this past game, unfortunately, and didn't get the win.

"We've got a good group of guys," he said. "It's important to guys. We feel like we're going to keep fighting, we're going to keep preparing, and going out there and still chase that feeling of that locker room after a win. That's a good feeling. It makes the week go easier. It makes Mondays feel better. It makes Tuesdays, it makes everything just easier to take when you're winning football games. So, that's what we're chasing."

You want to blame Shurmur for calling his own plays, ignoring Barkley in the second half and failing to score enough points to win, don't you? That might be fair, but with a 2-to-1 pass/run ratio, he at least tried to take advantage of the Eagles banged up secondary. However, there has been no clear explanation as to why Barkley had just five touches in the second half after scoring twice and racking up over 100 yards of total offense in the first half. Shurmur's team failed to adjust to the Eagles' adjustments and it cost the Giants the game.

You want to blame the offensive line, but the unit had a decent if not stellar afternoon; better on passing plays than on rushing downs. You can't blame kicker Aldrick Rosas, but you could ding punter Riley Dixon, who had a 56-yarder but also a shank that set the Eagles up for points.

You could blame the defense, which allowed 14 points in the second half against an offense it had dominated in the first. In fact, you can pointedly blame the run defense, which allowed 39 rushing yards in the first half then 88 in the second half for a total of 127 yards and a touchdown. The defense let the Eagles control the ball for nearly 20 of the final minutes and dominate on all fronts.

Oh, and that defense was seemingly without defensive end Olivier Vernon, who has all but disappeared in the last few weeks despite being apparently healthy and on the field for 86 percent of the plays on Sunday.

"This game didn't work out in the way we wanted it to," Shurmur said when asked about what it takes to keep the team from giving games away at the end. Tongue in cheek, perhaps? "Two weeks prior, it did. They had the ball, the two games that we've won, the team we were playing had the ball at the end and we didn't let them in the end zone. That was good. Yesterday was not."

How about the officials, who failed to call an interference penalty against the Eagles that prevented Odell Beckham Jr. from catching a potential touchdown? The crew also missed a leg-whipping penalty near the end of the game that would have given the Giants and Rosas a 63-yard field goal try. While that may have been unlikely, it would have given them a chance ... except that every team gets bad calls against them (and, in turn, for them as well) and suffers at the hands of the officiating crew regularly. That's the human element and it won't change anytime soon.

That's it? No one else to blame? No, this is a team in transition if no a total rebuild. Let's not forget, we're approaching the one-year anniversary of the termination of former general manager Jerry Reese and head coach Ben McAdoo. New GM Dave Gettleman has purged about 60 percent of last year's roster, and a few gambles haven't all worked out as well as the team hoped they would.

Wait until next year? With a team like this, that might be the best strategy of all. More on that later, but there another phase of the rebuilding process is looms large now.

Send it all over to and follow me on Twitter @_AaronKlein
Don't forget to follow us on Twitter @E_Giants

Check out Dave's website at E-GIANTS where you can subscribe to his newsletters which run much more frequently than what is available here.
- Team Giants

NOW - Send a request to for a free week's worth of news!

Previous Articles
Special Report

BYE Week
Special Report

Special Report

Pat Shurmur
Special Report

Giants Roster

Click on the Team Giants logo to be informed of all Giants game previews,
reviews and off season football news.

Stop in and visit "Mike's Keys to the Internet" at
Website by Mike