Team Giants


Special Report

Sent: 2-19-18

Dave Klein was the Giants' beat writer for The Star-Ledger from 1961 to 1995.
He is the author of 26 books and he is one of only three sportswriters to have covered all the Super Bowls. Dave has allowed TEAM GIANTS to reprint some of his articles.


By Dave Klein

Giant fans might point to 1979, when the Giants picked quarterback Phil Simms in the first round of the draft as the best day in franchise history.

Others might move ahead just a couple of years to 1981, when they chose linebacker Lawrence Taylor as their first round selection. Still others might select 2004, when the trade winds struck and the Giants came away with quarterback Eli Manning in the first round.

And a few of the older guys might point to 1951, when a running back from SMU named Kyle Rote turned into the team's premier pick. Or the following year when another running back - a kid named Frank Gifford from USC - became the team's first selection.

All are welcome, valid votes, and nothing wrong can be found with any of them, because what did anybody know at the time those selections were made?

But the worst day in the Giants' first-round drafting history? No, not 1964 when they took a running back from Oklahoma named Joe Don Looney; no, not 10 years later, when the pick turned out to be a tackle named John Hicks, who ate better than he played and ultimately ate himself out of the NFL; and not in (2002) when the running back Ron Dayne turned in his No. 1 draft card, and not even 2003, when a defensive tackle from the University of Miami named William Joseph proved without a doubt that he couldn't play the game.

You have to dig a little and go back to 1965, when the Giants owned the very first draft pick in the league, and they used it to select a 6-2, 220-pound running back from Auburn named Tucker Frederickson. Not that Tuck was a poor choice - he played six years for the Giants and finished with 651 carries for 2,209 yards and nine touchdowns.

The problem was this: The Chicago Bears had the next two choices, the second and third in that draft, and they selected a running back named Gale Sayers and a middle linebacker named Dick Butkus.

Both, of course, are in the Pro Football Hall of Fame, and just imagine how their presence in Yankee Stadium and as road warriors would have impacted the team. "I remained friendly with Tucker through the years," said the late Wellington Mara much later. "He was a gentleman, a wonderful person and a great athlete. But we both reflected on what might have been if the Bears held that first pick and we had ‘settled' on Sayers and Butkus."


So now we are getting ever closer to the Giants' 2018 draft - a memorable moment of truth since they have the second overall pick and only the Cleveland Browns, who are 1-31 for the last two seasons, will be able to snatch away an outstanding player.

They won't, of course, but will the Giants find a Sayers or a Butkus, or a potential Hall of Fame quarterback or running back, or a Lawrence Taylor or a Michael Strahan?

Stay tuned.

Not that the 1965 draft was another flop. The Giants actually reeled in many top-quality players that year, including Frederickson, safety Spider Lockhart, cornerback Henry Carr, running back Chuck Mercein, cornerback Willie Williams, running back Ernie Koy, linebacker Olen Underwood, linebacker Jim Carroll and running back Smith Reed.

But oh, the thought of Sayers or Butkus on the team still lingers to this day. And will the Giants make a similar choice in April? One that will provide memories and statistics and victories and Hall of Fame consideration? Or will they take another William Joseph or Ron Dayne?

Check out Dave's website at E-GIANTS where you can subscribe to his newsletters which run much more frequently than what is available here.
- Team Giants

NOW - Send a request to for a free week's worth of news!

Previous Articles
Special Report

The Draft
Special Report

Dave Gettleman
Special Report

Davis Webb - Eli Apple
Special Report


Click on the Team Giants logo to be informed of all Giants game previews,
reviews and off season football news.

Stop in and visit "Mike's Keys to the Internet" at
Website by Mike